Cookie banners that ask honestly: declining as easy as accepting
Many cookie banners show a big button to accept and hide the No. Others load Google fonts or analytics before anyone has been asked. This article shows what an honest banner looks like and what has to happen behind it technically.
What makes a banner honest
Buttons of the same size
“Decline” and “Accept” sit side by side, the same size and equally easy to read. Nobody has to click into settings first to say no.
Nothing loads before
Analytics and marketing start only after consent. Until then, no request goes to Google or other services.
Fonts from your own server
Fonts from Google Fonts pass the visitor’s IP address to Google. If the fonts are on your own server, that does not happen.
Change it at any time
A link in the footer opens the banner again, so visitors can change their decision later.
How to check your own banner
Open your website in a private window and tap “Decline”. Is the button on the first layer? Do analytics or maps still load afterwards? You can see this in the browser’s developer tools under “Network”: before consent there should be no connection to Google services.
Our own banner on steyer.studio works exactly like this. Try it: tap “Decline” once, then “Cookies” in the footer.
What courts have decided
There are judgments on both points: on the design of cookie banners from the Administrative Court of Hanover, and on fonts loaded from Google from the Regional Court of Munich I. The case numbers are listed below under sources.
This is not legal advice. You remain responsible for the text of your privacy policy. We make sure the technology matches it.
Read on
Sources
- Administrative Court of Hanover (Verwaltungsgericht Hannover), judgment of 19 March 2025, ref. 10 A 5385/22 (cookie banners)
- Regional Court of Munich I (Landgericht München I), judgment of 20 January 2022, ref. 3 O 17493/20 (Google Fonts)
Related articles
What happens after a tap on “Book”?
What happens on your hotel website after a tap on “Book”? An enquiry, someone else’s window or a booking, and how an interface to the channel manager helps.Online booking and still fast: how a Next.js website keeps up its speed
Booking on the website and still fast? How Next.js does it, what loading time is worth and which small things slow a site down. With sources and a measurement.The website check: what it tests and how to read the result
How well does your website work for Google and AI search? What our free website check tests, how to read the grades and what happens to your data.
Questions about your project?
30 minutes on Teams, free and without obligation.